When it comes to designing a bathroom, one common question clients ask is: shower curtain vs glass door—what’s better? The truth is, there’s no one-size-fits-all answer. It depends on the bathroom’s layout, who’s using it, and your design goals.
After years of designing bathrooms of all sizes and styles, I’ve seen clear patterns emerge. Many homeowners prefer a glass shower door in the primary bathroom for its sleek and modern look. However, in guest or kid-friendly bathrooms—especially those with bathtubs—a shower curtain often makes more sense.
Let’s break down the pros and cons of both options so you can make the right decision for your space.
The Shower Curtain: Flexible and Budget-Friendly
The Upside:
Shower curtains offer flexibility and personality. They come in endless patterns, colors, and materials—making them a great way to tie into your bathroom décor. You can easily switch them out seasonally or as your style evolves. Plus, when left open, a curtain can make a smaller bathroom feel more spacious.
The Downside:
Shower curtains require more maintenance than you might think. The inner liner should be replaced or thoroughly cleaned every 6–8 weeks to prevent mildew buildup. Without regular care, a curtain setup can quickly look dingy.
The Glass Shower Door: Sleek and Long-Lasting
The Upside:
A glass shower door gives your bathroom a more high-end, custom feel. Frameless designs in particular offer a seamless, modern look. They also tend to contain water better than curtains, reducing the risk of floor damage from splashes.
The Downside:
Glass doors show water spots and soap scum if not cleaned regularly. Models with tracks can collect grime and may need occasional deep cleaning with vinegar or non-abrasive cleaners. That said, upgrading to ½-inch thick glass and selecting a protective coating can make maintenance easier and extend the door’s lifespan.
Shower Curtain vs Glass Door: Which Is Best?
Here’s a quick guide to help you decide:
-
Master Bathroom: Go with a glass shower door—especially for walk-in showers. It adds sophistication and long-term value to your space.
-
Guest Bathroom: Either option works, but if the shower includes a tub, a curtain makes cleaning and bathing children much easier.
-
Kid’s Bathroom: A curtain is often the better choice for safety, flexibility, and ease of use.
Designer Tip
If you do opt for a glass door, investing in ½-inch tempered glass is worth it. The added durability and improved look are well worth the modest price difference. Some manufacturers also offer a protective coating that helps prevent water stains and mineral buildup, keeping your bathroom looking newer, longer.
Looking for a trusted vendor? I highly recommend Dennis at Premier Glass for quality installation and excellent service.
When deciding between a shower curtain vs glass door, consider your lifestyle, cleaning preferences, and design goals. A curtain may be more practical in high-use, family-friendly bathrooms, while a glass door can elevate the look and function of a primary bath. Whichever option you choose, make sure it supports both your daily routine and long-term needs.